How many types of technical papers do exist on earth (QUALITATIVE CLASSIFICATION from a graduate student with 21 months' experience in reading papers]
1) "WOW!!" [great ones - usually the ones I don't understand]
2) "NICE" [good ones - usually the ones I partially understand but can prepare a 15 min ppt on one]
3) "HMMMM" [mediocre ones - can give an hour's talk on one]
4) "COUNTER++" [ones just to increase no. of publication of author(s) (read desperate PhD students just before graduation)- often no. of authors of a paper in this category exceed no. of useful sentences in the paper]
5) "?????????????" [finally the ones I cannot categorize due to limited whatever from whoever - me or the author(s)]
P.S. there is another category - the one's I write - I have enough ego not to include them in the last two categories and enough honesty not to include them in any other.
P.S. (2) It is all for fun, graduate students and their advisors are not supposed to refer to this blog in any further publication, or sue me, or take me seriously :P
No comments:
Post a Comment